IT TAKES A VILLAGE
Â IT TAKES A VILLAGE
Written by Roshi Eve Myonen Marko
Photo by Peter Cunningham, of Eve at the 2015 Native American Bearing Witness Retreat
Bernie and I went to the movies and saw â€śSpotlightâ€ť yesterday. Itâ€™s a terrific film about the group of Boston Globe journalists who reported on the extensive abuse of minors by many Catholic priests in Boston. I canâ€™t recommend this movie highly enough.
I particularly appreciated that it didnâ€™t portray the journalists as pure, white-horse knights going out to seek the truth and slay deniers and perpetrators. It showed, in fact, that they had received several tips in prior years about what was going on, and theyâ€™d shut their eyes to it, like many others, or didnâ€™t bother to put the dots together and present the fullÂ story till much later, after many more children had been abused.
I thought of the abuse Iâ€™ve seen in dharma centers. Itâ€™s easy to say that it was nothing like the horrific scale of what went on in various Catholic dioceses across the world. Itâ€™s easy to point out that, at least in the West, children are almost never involved if only because most of our dharma centers donâ€™t have family programs. But weâ€™ve certainly had our share of abuse by teachers of students.
This morning Iâ€™m thinking about the silence that supports these things. Iâ€™m thinking about the subtle moments that some of us experienced, when thereâ€™s a dissonance between what I hear and what I see, and I withdraw and remain silent rather than ask uncomfortable questions. This goes both ways. Iâ€™ve watched teachers hide behind authority, and Iâ€™ve also seen students let go of responsibility. Iâ€™ve watched many practitioners, including me, seek in a like-minded group a refuge from living responsibly in the world, learning how to deal with money and each other, and accepting the consequences of our decisions and our actions. A place where we wonâ€™t have to grow up. Who has lived or practiced for years in a dharma center without witnessing some of these patterns?
A new consciousness seeks to change these ways. What has happened in Catholic dioceses is a flashing-red-sign warning to everyone of what can happen when an entire system not only permits abuse, but then protects and sheathes it in a tight cocoon of silence. As one character says in the film, if it takes a village to raise a child, it takes a village to destroy the child. Itâ€™s never just one person, itâ€™s many.
If mindfulness means something, it should at least be a practice of detecting a lack of comfort in myself, a desire to hide or get away, shut my eyes, or say something completely bland and noncommittal. It should at least reflect back to me my desire to disengage from whatever calls for attention.
Bernie Glassman likes to say that weâ€™re all members of clubs. I think of it more like that weâ€™re all members of systems, and as such we have our roles. In my life, one of those systems for sure has been the dharma center, in which every single person plays a role, even if you only come occasionally to hear a talk. There are teachers, senior students, retreat participants, people who come for classes, people who just come to sit. But are there any bystandersâ€”or bysitters? Can anyone just come to sit and not want to know about anything else? I think one can believe that a million times over, and it wonâ€™t change the fact that you are playing a role there, even if a seemingly passive one, and that comes with the responsibility to be faithful to your own experience of things, to the sensations that arise in certain situations, and to the mechanisms we use to block them off.
I am now a Zen teacher myself, viewed as someone high on the authority pole, or at least higher than other folks in our small zendo. As any teacher can attest, teaching is a huge learning about expectations (including my own) and projections (including my own). There are people who have told me that a certain exchange with me in the recent or distant past changed their lives. There are also people who canâ€™t forgive me, they say, for words Iâ€™ve uttered.
I listen carefully to both extreme views. Personally, I feel that the vastness of life dwarfs the impact that any one teacher can have. I donâ€™t say this out of humility or as a defense of myself or others, simply that no one person can be singlehandedly responsible for another adultâ€™s basic pattern of relationship or behavior, those things develop over time and as a result of many interactions.
I try to focus on the smaller stuff: the person whose eyes I donâ€™t like to meet, the situation when I canâ€™t summon up the energy to be engaged. The times I say itâ€™s not my business. Itâ€™s a small but important first step: When do I feel uncomfortable? Whatâ€”or whomâ€”donâ€™t I wish to look at? What donâ€™t I wish to express? Itâ€™s bearing witness to backing off.
The poet Christian Wiman has written in his great book, â€śMy Bright Abyssâ€ť: â€śFor many people, God is simply a gauze applied to the wound of not knowing.â€ť But God is certainly not the only band-aid around.
Read more of Eve’s writings atÂ www.evemarko.com[/box]
Bearing Witness at Bear Butte: Reflection from The Wounded Knee Massacre Descendants Conference, October 2017
November 07, 2017
October 25, 2017